The Best Kohl Eyeliners To Make the Perfect Smokey Eye

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

If you're craving a sultry, smokey, smudged liner look, look no further than a kohl eyeliner. Stemming back to ancient Egypt, as in—when people would literally grind up charcoal to use as eye makeup (do not try at home), the dark pigmented-style liner still lives on today. Kohl liners pack a similarly dramatic punch, but with more advanced formulas, of course.

But, there is a twist. The ingredient itself is unapproved for cosmetic use in the United States, and kohl eyeliners typically refer to the color of the liner (a dark blackish-charcoal color) and the super-soft formula. Kohl consists of salts of heavy metals, including lead, and should be avoided in cosmetics. That being said, the easy-to-apply easy-to-smudge "kohl" liners you find in stores are safe and has the ability to give you the smokey eye of your dreams.

Ahead, the best kohl (colored) eyeliners out there.

Best Overall: Charlotte Tilbury Rock N Kohl Liquid Eye Pencil in Eye Cheat

4.5
Charlotte Tilbury Rock N Kohl Liquid Eye Pencil in Eye Cheat
What We Like
  • Waterproof

  • Goes on smoothly

  • Supports natural collagen production

What We Don't Like
  • Might smudge a bit

Who else recommends it? Cosmopolitan and Allure both picked the Charlotte Tilbury Liquid Eye Pencil. 

What do buyers say? 85% of 500+ Nordstrom reviewers rated this product 4 stars or above.

Although it’s called kohl, this formula is really more of a liquid-kohl hybrid. It boasts the supremely silky application of a liquid, though with the easily-smudged texture of kohl. (And if you really want to up the smudge factor, just buff it out with a brush.) It’s waterproof, lasting up to 14 hours, and is infused with crushed pearl powder to hydrate the delicate skin around your eyes. While there’s a nice range of dark shades to choose from, the eye-opening nude tone is also a must-try.

Type: Liquid-Kohl | Shades: 3 | Free of: Parabens | Size: 0.04 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: No

Best Overall, Runner-Up: Make Up For Ever Kohl Pencil

Make Up For Ever Kohl Pencil

Courtesy of Sephora

What We Like
  • Ultra-blendable

  • Good for even the most sensitive eyes

  • Easy to use

What We Don't Like
  • Not very long-lasting

For those seeking a classic, simple black kohl liner, this is the one to go with. It does just come in the one black shade, but the formula is one of the smoothest we’ve ever used. Credit the addition of tons of hydrating ingredients, including vegetable lipids, vitamin E, and mango seed oil, just to name a few. Plus, the pigments are also specially formulated to be ultra-blendable.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 1 | Free of: Parabens, Alcohol | Size: 0.0402 oz. | Cruelty-Free: No | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best Budget: Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil

4.2
Rimmel London ScandalEyes Waterproof Kohl Eye Liner

Walmart

What We Like
  • High intensity color

  • Smudge-free

  • Quick-drying

  • Comes with thin professional brush

What We Don't Like
  • Sparkle version lacks sufficient shimmer

Yes, that price is correct. This drugstore staple is a fan favorite, rivaling (if not outperforming) many of its much pricier counterparts. The waterproof formula means it won’t run, even if you apply it in your waterline, and touts a gel formula that glides along skin without ever pulling or tugging—our biggest eyeliner pet peeve.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 7 | Free of: Alcohol | Size: 0.004 oz. | Cruelty-Free: No | Byrdie Clean: No

Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil

Byrdie / Ashley Rebecca

What Our Testers Say

"I found the liner did not run or smear on me throughout the day, and I was impressed with how efficiently it stayed in the waterline." —Ashley Rebecca, Product Tester

Best Drugstore: NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil in Taupe

NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil in Taupe
What We Like
  • Wide range of shades

  • Easy to remove

  • Bold aesthetic

What We Don't Like
  • Difficult to remove

There are plenty of great eyeliners to be found at the drugstore, but this is one of our faves. It’s one of the brand’s best-sellers for a reason, containing hydrating coconut oil for a silky texture and feel, plus a dizzying array of 24 shades to pick from. And no matter which hue you choose, the rich pigments pack a serious color punch.

Type: Kohl-Pencil | Shades: 24 | Free of: Alcohol, Parabens | Size: 0.04 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: No

What Our Editors Say

"The slim eye pencil from NYX is my go-to when I want a pop of color. It’s creamy, pigmented, and available for a great price. I personally love the purple and lavender shimmer shades because they bring out the amber in my brown eyes." —Madeline Hirsch, Senior News Editor

Best Waterproof: Kulfi Underlined Kajal Eyeliner

Kulfi Underlined Kajal Eyeliner
What We Like
  • Infused with antioxidants

  • Highly pigmented

  • Even works on oily eyelids

What We Don't Like
  • Not compatible with moisturizer

Sure, you want a kohl liner to look smudgy, but you also want to be able to control those smudges and not have them happen on their own accord. Enter this option, a favorite of celebrity makeup artist Jamie Greenberg (who notes that kajal and kohl are the same things, FYI). “It’s waterproof and doesn’t move, even staying on the waterline nicely,” she says.

Type: Kohl-Kajal | Shades: 5 | Free of: Alcohol, Parabens | Size: 0.012 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best for Easy Application: Jillian Dempsey Kohl Eyeliner

Jillian Dempsey Kohl Eyeliner
What We Like
  • Preservative-free

  • Full of vitamins and oils

  • Soft but effective blender tip

What We Don't Like
  • Tends to fade

If you want to get that kohl eyeliner effect but aren’t quite sure how to achieve it, try this guy. The dual-ended pencil features a silky tip on one end that delivers just the right amount of pigment and a built-in smudger on the other, great for buffing out the color. The formula is also totally natural and cruelty-free, filled with organic jojoba oil, marula oil, and shea butter.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 4 | Free of: Alcohol, Parabens | Size: 0.012 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: Yes

What Our Editors Say

“So soft and silky, it just glides over inner and outer rims for a perfectly defined eye. I love the smudger—makes for a perfectly imperfect look. I'm partial to the Deep Burgundy shade. " —Leah Wyar, SVP/GM

Best Double-Duty: Stila Stay All Day Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner
What We Like
  • Lasts up to 12 hours

  • Immediate color payoff

  • Very moisturizing

What We Don't Like
  • Hard to apply and remove

“This is another fabulous formula that glides on and literally stays in place all day,” says Greenberg. (More specifically, the waterproof pick lasts up to 12 hours.) But what we love most of all is that the creamy formula pulls double-duty, working just as well as a liner as it does as a shadow; just buff on all-over with your fingertips or a brush if you want to use it as the latter. It’s also nice for those who don’t love traditional pencil formats, with a twist-up tip that requires no sharpening.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 12 | Free of: Alcohol, Parabens | Size: 0.01 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: No

Best Shade Range: MAC Eye Kohl Pencil

 MAC Cosmetics

What We Like
  • Silky smooth, matte, or pearl finish

  • Glides on easily

  • Really makes the eyes pop

What We Don't Like
  • Not very transfer-resistant

A true cult classic, we appreciate that this pick comes not only in a line-up of the classic dark shades you’d expect from a kohl formula—black, brown—but also some more unexpected colors and a variety of finishes, too. There’s a bright mint with a pearlized finish and a beautiful shimmery bronze, just to name a few. Either way, the pencil glides on smoothly and has the added benefit of being an ophthalmologist-tested, a boon for those with sensitive eyes.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 5 | Free of: Fragrance, Oil, Formaldehyde, Hydroquinone, Triclosan, Coal Tar, Toluene, Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Gluten, Phthalate, Parabens, Mineral Oil, Petrolatum, Polyethylene, Lauryl Sulfate, Oxybenzone | Size: 0.04 oz. | Cruelty-Free: No | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best Shade Range, Runner-Up: Younique Moodstruck Precision Pencil Eyeliner

Younique Moodstruck Precision Pencil Eyeliner
What We Like
  • Smudge-free

  • Full of natural ingredients

  • Variety of fun colors

What We Don't Like
  • Can apply in a blotchy way

Greenberg loves the “smooth and soft formula,” as well as all of the colors this pencil comes in. Speaking of, these aren’t just your basic shades but some more unique options, think a robin’s egg blue, royal purple, and crisp white that can be used along the waterline to help make you look more awake.

Type: Kohl-Liquid | Shades: 7 | Free of: Fragrance, Formaldehyde, Hydroquinone, Triclosan, Coal Tar, Toluene, Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Gluten, Phthalate, Parabens, Mineral Oil, Petrolatum, Polyethylene, Lauryl Sulfate, Oxybenzone | Size: 0.04 oz. | Cruelty-Free: No | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best for a Dramatic Effect: Rituel de Fille The Black Orb Engimatic Eyeliner

Rituel de Fille The Black Orb Engimatic Eyeliner
What We Like
  • Rich, semi-matte finish

  • Gives a very dramatic look

  • Only made with natural ingredients

  • Buildable

What We Don't Like
  • Pricey

For anyone looking to really drive home the smokey, smoldering eye vibes that you get with a kohl liner, this pick can’t be beaten. The name says it all; instead of coming in a traditional pencil, this is, well, an orb of deeply pigmented black kohl pigment. You can apply it as you would a powder, using an angled liner brush, though it’s so creamy and intense that it can even be smudged on the lower and upper lash line with your fingertips for a very dramatic look. Happy users rave about how buildable the color is, too.

Type: Kohl-Cream | Shades: 1 | Free of: Fragrance, Parabens, Alcohol | Size: 0.24 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best for a Natural Effect: Laura Mercier Kohl Eye Pencil

Laura Mercier 
What We Like
  • Formulated specifically for lining inside of eyelid

  • Lasts all day

  • Metallic version looks dynamic

What We Don't Like
  • Doesn't go on smoothly

To be fair, kohl liners are more often associated with an ultra-dramatic, in-your-face, smokey eye. But they can also be used to create a more subdued look, particularly if you try this option. Why? The unique tip has a thicker diameter than other liners, specially made to help line the inside of the eyelid at the base of the lashes, a technique that makes for an eye-opening yet natural effect.

Type: Kohl | Shades: 3 | Free of: Fragrance, Gluten, Phthalate, Parabens, Petrolatum | Size: 0.04 oz. | Cruelty-Free: No | Byrdie Clean: Yes

Best Splurge: Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner

Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner
What We Like
  • Decadent brown shade

  • Great staying power

  • Dermatologist tested

What We Don't Like
  • Could be more durable in construction

This pick may be pricey, but it’s well worth every penny. It’s supremely creamy, never tugging or skipping, and highly pigmented. It’s also a top choice for anyone with sensitive eyes, ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-tested, and safe to use on the waterline, even for contact lens wearers. Not to mention that the dual-sided pencil comes with a built-in smudger on one end.

Type: Kohl-Kajal | Shades: 8 | Free of: Fragrance | Size: 0.042 oz. | Cruelty-Free: Yes | Byrdie Clean: No

What Our Editors Say

The Victoria Beckham Satin Kajal Liner is the smoothest kohl liner I’ve ever used. It glides on effortlessly and is highly-pigmented for maximum color payoff, but my favorite aspect is the smudger—it makes for crazy-easy smokey eyes.” —Karli Bendlin, Senior Editor

Final Verdict

Kohl eyeliners are ideal for those looking for a smudgy, smokey effect. The Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eyeliner (view at Sephora) is our top choice—super silky, long-lasting, and available in a nice range of colors. Newbies will appreciate that the Jillian Dempsey Kohl Eyeliner (view at Credo Beauty) is a dual-ended option with a built-in smudger that makes application easier than ever (and also has a squeaky clean, natural formula). Meanwhile, the NYX Professional Makeup Slim Eye Pencil Long-Lasting Eyeliner (view at Ulta) is a top drugstore pick with a wallet-friendly price tag and jaw-droppingly extensive shade range. Or try the Stila Stay All Day Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner (view at Ulta), a two-in-one with a stay-put, waterproof formula that works just as well as a liner as it does an eye shadow.

What to Look for in a Kohl Eyeliner

Kohl or Kajal

Greenberg points out that two mean the same thing and are often used interchangeably. Seeing either term on a pencil is a sign that it has that silky, easy to smudge texture you're after.

Soft, Moveable Texture

It's this soft texture that will allow you to create a smokey look. Make sure to opt for a pick that doesn't tug at the delicate skin around your eyes.

How Quickly It Sets

Because a kohl formula is meant to be smudged out, you’ll ideally want to find an option that gives you enough playtime to work with it before it totally sets in place, points out Greenberg.

FAQ
  • How do you sharpen kohl eyeliners?

    There’s nothing fancy or special you need to do here; just a traditional, classic eyeliner sharpener will get the job done, says Greenberg.

  • How do you apply kohl eyeliners?

    Because these are so soft and creamy, your best bet is to first create small dashes, suggests Greenberg. Then use an angled liner brush, or even your finger, to blend these dashes so that they connect into one line. Continue buffing if you’re after a more smudged effect.

  • Do kohl eyeliners expire?

    Not in the traditional sense, but it is a good idea to replace any pencil eyeliner after about a year of use, or sooner if you have any kind of eye infection.

Why Trust Byrdie?

Byrdie contributor Melanie Rud has over a decade of experience in the beauty industry, writing for some of the biggest magazines and websites out there. Kohl eyeliner is her preferred liner formula of choice, which she likes to use to line her top waterline.

Meet the Expert

Jamie Greenberg is a celebrity makeup artist based in Los Angeles. She frequently works with celebrities such as Chelsea Handler and Kaley Cuoco, has done campaigns with major beauty brands, and is also known for her editorial work.

According to our Diversity Pledge, 15% of products in our newly-published market roundups will feature Black-owned and/or Black-founded brands. At the time of publishing, we were not able to find any kohl eyeliners from a Black-owned and/or Black-founded business. If you know of one we should consider, please email us at contact@byrdie.com and we will evaluate the product ASAP.

Article Sources
Byrdie takes every opportunity to use high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial guidelines to learn more about how we keep our content accurate, reliable and trustworthy.
  1. https://www.fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetic-products/eye-cosmetic-safety

  2. 17 Absolute Best Eyeliners That Won't Run, Budge, or Smudge. Cosmopolitan. https://www.cosmopolitan.com/style-beauty/beauty/g25643335/best-eyeliner/

  3. The Best Waterproof Eyeliners for Tightlining Your Waterline. Allure. https://www.allure.com/gallery/best-eyeliner-for-waterline

Related Stories